Skip to main content Skip to header navigation

You Already Have About A Million Kids’ Halloween Costumes In Your House — Here’s How To Find Them

Halloween literally freaks me out. Every. Single. Year. My kids have great expectations surrounding the day (not a holiday in my book, BTW) which — as a mom who kind of despises the occasion — can be daunting. Over the years, my kids have scoured costume catalogs teeming with astronomically priced accessories, and we’ve even succumbed to a few trends. (Once, I splurged on an Elsa wig which, after the first 10 steps of the Halloween parade at school, my daughter deemed hot and itchy before promptly tossing it. It’s currently up for grabs if anyone fancies it in anticipation of Frozen 2 being released next month.)

But nowadays, rather than lose my head over the predictable challenge of culling costumes each fall, I have a new go-to mantra when preparing for the ghastly arrival of Halloween: Use what you’ve got, and don’t sweat the rest.

This approach to DIY Halloween costumes is a win for anyone keen on avoiding the tricks leading up to October 31 in favor of reaping the treats. As to the cardinal rule? Employ fresh eyes to look at what you’ve already got lying around.

Embrace dual personalities

Go ahead and scour the dress-up trunk. A pair of surgical scrubs — coupled with a plastic stethoscope and a handmade name tag — and voilà! You’ve got a tiny doctor or nurse on your hands. Got a superhero cape and/or mask floating around? Help your child imagine a new character and emblazon the cape with the corresponding letter or symbol using paper-cutouts or duct tape. (Tip: Using your child’s first name is a great place to start. Think Super Sam.) You might even score a bit of mom-kid bonding time thinking up silly adjectives to describe each other (and yes, I did dress up as Super Mom one year). 

Think uniformity

View this post on Instagram

Sugarplum 🍭 #maraisskygirls

A post shared by MARAIS SKY® [ma-ray sky] (@maraisskyofficial) on

We’ve gotten tons of mileage out of old ballet clothing in our house. Either current or hand-me-down, activity-specific clothing can be combined in myriad ways for dressing up. One year, I had a five-year-old who wanted to be the Tooth Fairy (you do know she dresses in old ballet costumes for work, right?) My daughter picked a color scheme — pink, in this case — and we layered tights, leotard, tutu, cardigan sweater, and crown. The pièce de résistance was an old wand with a clip-art tooth printed, laminated and stuck to the end with Scotch tape.

The same goes for sports uniforms: My 13-year-old donned a favorite hockey jersey (Jack Eichel of the Buffalo Sabres) and pilfered my 1980s-era eyeshadow to craft a bruiser of a black eye (that was surprisingly realistic). Recycle old sports uniforms — soccer, baseball, basketball, you name it — and quickly personalize your child’s jersey with a favorite player’s name and/or number using fabric/electrical/duct tape. 

Get comfortable

Lazy loaded image
Image: Courtesy of Hannah Van Sickle. Courtesy of Hannah Van Sickle.

Who doesn’t love pajamas? Especially if you’ve got a kiddo with sensory integration issues, costumes can be itchy and downright infuriating. Look no further than a pair of favorite pjs. Last year, my 12-year-old was studying Dia de los Muertos in Spanish class; then she remembered an old pair of black pajamas with glow-in-the-dark skeleton bones on them. This outfit, coupled with a bit of face paint and a handful of dollar-store flowers twisted into a crown, left her poised to enjoy hours of fun trick-or-treating with her friends sans irritation. Red-and-white striped pajamas can be recycled for Where’s Waldo?, and black-and-white stripes can do double-duty as an inmate. 

And pajamas aren’t the only comfy standby; the same goes for any other duds in which your kid enjoys spending time. Got an equestrian? Dress up as a jockey. A budding martial artist? Like magic, give them a black belt. 

Get creative

View this post on Instagram

How is this for a box costume!? The Swan Princess 🦢 beautifully created by the incredibly talented @mer_mag – perfect to whip up this weekend if you have book week next week! Just like our own Swan Princess print! I’m trying to convince my little one to do this because I’ve been dying to make it for so long, but she’s adamant she is going to be a pirate. 🏴‍☠️ Click link in bio to be taken to the instructions. ⠀ ⠀ #bedheadhats #welovebedheadhats #sunsafe #kidshats #babyhats #girlshat #boyshat #unisexhat #slipslopslap #upf50 #hats #sunhats #sunhat #kidsfashion #springfashion #springhats #springprints #outdoorkids #naturekids #wildexplorersclub #getoutside #swanprincess #diycostume #boxcostume #bookweek #swan

A post shared by Bedhead Hats (@bedhead_hats) on

Creative kids will love the challenge of making their own costume out of a box, and it will occupy them — for hours. One year, when I was pregnant, I fashioned a replica gas range out of a giant cardboard box and transformed my swollen self into a “bun in the oven” for the night. My oldest daughter made a Ms. Pacman sandwich-board-style costume out of cardboard and paint one year, which she accented with a pink bow for her hair; several years before that, when Minecraft was wildly popular, she hand-painted a giant box with tiny squares and became Steve. Cardboard is also great for making swords, shields, wands and other miscellaneous embellishments for myriad costumes. 

Play grown-up

Or, at the very least, let your kids. Grab an apron, a white hat, and a wooden spoon from the kitchen to create an instant chef; hunt up an old tool belt, sling a hammer through one of the loops, and tuck a pencil behind your child’s ear, and you’ve built a carpenter; the sky’s the limit here. Especially if you are willing to part with a few of your favorite (read: replaceable) possessions for a few hours (think armfuls of bangle bracelets; patterned silk scarves; makeup). Do you wear a uniform for work? Offer to let your child be you for a day (in exchange for a hefty fraction of their candy haul, of course).

If all else fails, buy cheap

So your daughter wants to be Harley Quinn and you’re not crazy about her ripping up her new black tights and painting her denim jacket? If all else fails, (thrift) shop around. A slew of options — from Goodwill and local thrift shops to dollar stores and Target — can get your creative juices flowing. 

Go ahead and breathe a sigh of relief. This just might be the year you survive October unscathed by the cost and irritation that comes from the dreaded costume hunt. Now that’s a treat.

Leave a Comment