Not all liners are in stick form. In fact, one of our absolute favorites comes in a pot! This cream eyeliner by Smashbox is applied with a brush, giving you total control over the application process so you can customize your makeup look completely. The cream formula also has remarkable staying power. The liner comes in many gorgeous colors however we’re particularly smitten with “Picasso,” a deep ink blue color. $22 from Sephora.com. Can’t decide on a color? Get ten of them in an adorable and convenient palette that also comes with a mini brush. It makes a perfect stocking stuffer come holiday gifting time, though it will certainly be hard to give away. $32 from Sephora.com.