If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.
It’s no secret that we’ve got a thing for Etsy. There’s really nothing you can’t find on the handmade site — whether that’s an embroidery hoop or their seriously chic collection of Black-owned home brands — but we truly were floored when we discovered just how many tasty treats you can find on Etsy. Sometimes we’re not always in the mood to whip up things from scratch, even though we do love our online cooking and baking classes, so this baked-goods wonderland is always a solid resource to keep bookmarked for yourself and for gifts.
Shop for anything from French macarons and classic ready-made ooey-gooey chocolate chip cookies to dessert boxes that are sure to delight your tastebuds.
Below, check out the best baked goods on Etsy that you’re not shopping, but should be.
A version of this article was originally published August 2020.
2 Smart Cookies Bakery
For moist, creamy homemade pumpkin cream cheese roll cakes, look no farther than Etsy seller 2 Smart Cookies Bakery.
Dulcet Gift Baskets
If you need a tasty treat basket to send a friend or loved one, Dulcet Gift Baskets has you covered. Based in New York, this gourmet gift shop offers gift-wrapped treat boxes to satisfy your sweet tooth. They have themed sets and offer everything from bundt cakes to a variety of pastries.
Sweet Sammie Janes
We can’t help but drool when we look at the goodies this Etsy seller has to offer. Who knew you could score legit French macarons on the internet? So, if you can’t get to France, this is basically the next best thing.
Marb’s Baked Goods
The name says it all: Consider this seller baked goods heaven. Shop for decadent (and massive!) red velvet cookies you thought you could only dream about, a variety of fun pound cakes, and savory jalapeño corn bread.
Etsy seller Cincottis Homemade pans out gourmet sweet bread gifts that’ll have you coming back for more. Case in point: They’re mouthwatering coconut pineapple banana bread.
Indayani Baked Goods
Everything is just better when it’s bite sized, and these mouthwatering mini pies are no exception. This artisan bakery also offers other equally tasty and gorgeous goods, such as macarons and shortbread cookies you can get gift wrapped.
14th Street Vintage Art
This art store based in North Carolina certainly has some cool vintage home items, but what we can’t stop exploring is the baked goods section. Here, you’ll find a mix of vintage treats like oat waffle mix in a shabby chic mason jar or focaccia bread mix and soup for a complete meal.
J’s Crafts Dallas
If you’ve got an empanada craving, head to J’s Crafts Dallas. These aren’t your typical empanadas, though: Try the strawberry, pineapple, and pumpkin for some variety to delight your tastebuds. You’ll also find Mexican sweet breads and a collection of cool sugar skulls.
Keto bagels? Seriously. This baked goods seller on Etsy whips up fresh, low-carb treats that taste like the OG thing. Keto pizza crust, peanut butter cookies — you name it, they’ve got it. With over 10K sales, this is one seller to check out.
The Whipped Bakery
Want 2 pounds of cookies? The Whipped Bakery’s got your back. They even have a cookie subscription so you don’t have to worry about getting low on these fresh, gourmet treats. This award-winning bakery also serves up other cookie flavors and gorgeous Pinterest-worthy cakes for birthdays, gender reveals, or even your wedding.
Chickens in the Road
Chickens in the Road has been featured on Good Morning America and in the Wall Street Journal, so there’s gotta be something to these biscuits. Add their old-fashioned biscuit mixes, scones, or hand-crafted mixes to your cart, and your family will wonder how you became a gourmet chef overnight.
The Home Bakers
Nothing makes our stomach happier than some flaky, buttery Baklava. It’s not always the most common thing you can find around, so the fact that this Etsy seller has it is impressive. You can also shop for other Lebanese pastries and sweets from The Home Bakers.
Organic Bread of Heaven
Our favorite food group? Bread, bread, and more bread. So, this carb-loaded seller is at the top of our bookmark list. Stock up on fresh, organic tortillas to elevate taco night and other various types of starches.
2 Smart Cookies Bakery
Sure, we’ve seen this seller before, but we can’t help but mention them just one more time, specifically to rave about their apple fritter bread drizzled with a deliciously sweet frosting.
Leave a Comment