Skip to main content Skip to header navigation

Ina Garten Is Skipping the Mashed Potatoes This Year & Replacing Them With This Unexpected Dish

This Thanksgiving, throw the rules out the window and serve whatever the hell you want. Want to sip on oversized Quarantine Cosmos Ina Garten-style? Do it. Want to top the meal off with boozy, rum-infused desserts? We do, too. Bored with the tried-and-true mashed potatoes side dish? Do what Garten would do and swap it with creamy mashed butternut squash.

Garten recently shared her unique Thanksgiving spread with William Sonoma; and in addition to serving a Tuscan Turkey Roulade main dish stuffed with all your favorite flavors, including prosciutto, fennel seeds, garlic, fresh sage and rosemary, Garten’s mouthwatering menu also features an unexpected dish: Mashed Butternut Squash.

Our mission at SheKnows is to empower and inspire women, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale. 

Image: Williams Sonoma.

“It’s always exciting when a recipe evolves to the next level. One day I was making roasted butternut squash from The Barefoot Contessa Cookbook and decided to try it as a puree — and it’s even better!” Garten writes.

To make Garten’s mashed squash, you need just four simple ingredients: unsalted butter, light brown sugar, half-and-half, and, of course, butternut squash. The process is pretty simple, too: Basically, you cut the squash into cubes, roast with the butter, brown sugar, and salt and pepper for 40 minutes; puree the roasted ingredients and half-and-half in a food processor (we recommend this affordable Hamilton Beach food processor on Amazon); season to taste, and serve.

Hamilton Beach 10-Cup Food Processor $48.49 on Amazon.com Buy now

“If the squash is too thick, thin it with milk, orange juice or water,” Garten writes.

Garten also recommends pairing the mashed squash with a salty roasted veggie, like Brussels sprouts — “so you have contrasting flavors, colors and textures,” the Barefoot Contessa host explains.

What’s also great about this side dish, which is included in Garten’s cookbooks Barefoot Contessa Family Style: Easy Ideas and Recipes That Make Everyone Feel Like Family, is you can make it in advance. Simply reheat it covered in a microwave or in a bowl over a pot of simmering water.

Get the recipe for Garten’s Mashed Butternut Squash at Williams Sonoma. And while you’re on their website, why not also purchase a ticket for Garten’s virtual book tour featuring Katie Couric? Tickets range from $35 to $49.99 and include a copy of Garten’s Modern Comfort Food cookbook. The virtual event takes place Nov. 17 at 6:30 p.m. ET.

Before you go, check out our top foolproof holiday gifts for absolutely everyone on your list:

Leave a Comment