Skip to main content Skip to header navigation

13 Girl Scout cookie knockoff recipes you won’t feel guilty eating

Girl Scout Cookie season is upon us and it is hard to resist the temptation of those tasty treats. It doesn’t help that they are being sold outside every grocery store in the country!

It seems like they are targeting you at your weakest, when you have no food in the house and need to stock up. One box wouldn’t hurt, right? Well, one box inevitably turns into two or three or 10.

Now you have a reason to walk on by with your head held high. You can even tell those sweet young girls that you have some at home already. Because with these great low-carb and paleo Girl Scout cookie knockoffs, you will never be tempted again.

Thin Mints

Thin Mints are the most popular variety of Girl Scout cookies and it’s easy to make a healthier version. Here are three great recipes to make your own.

Image: Kate’s Healthy Cupboard

These low-carb Flourless Thin Mints rely on egg whites for their crisp texture.

Image: Lexi’s Clean Kitchen

Want a Girl Scout cookie recipe fit for a caveman? Try these Paleo Thin Mints.

Image: All Day I Dream About Food

Your cookies don’t have to be flat! Try these low-carb Thin Mint Truffles for a fun twist.


If the caramel coconutty goodness of Samoas (or Caramel DeLights) is more your style, take heart. Those too can be made into healthier cookies!

Image: Deliciously Organic

These Grain-Free Paleo Samoas rely on coconut sugar for sweetness.

Image: Maria Mind Body Health

Want your Samoas to be truly sugar free? Try this low-carb Samoa recipe.

Image: All Day I Dream About Food

Cutting cookies into circles makes for extra work. Why not just enjoy the same flavors in bar form? Low-Carb Samoa Bars.


Tagalongs may now be called Peanut Butter Patties, but no one can deny that the chocolate peanut butter combo is irresistible. These recipes make it easy to enjoy those flavors without blowing your healthy diet.

Image: Chocolate Covered Katie

This healthy vegan Tagalong recipe can be made with stevia or with maple syrup.

Image: Plated With Style

For a Paleo Tagalong recipe, try substituting the peanut butter with almond butter.

Image: Low-carbology

If you need to be sugar-free, these Low Carb Tagalongs might be just the thing.

Image: All Day I Dream About Food

Once again, it’s easier to make bars than fuss about cutting out cookies. These Low-Carb Tagalong Bars will satisfy that craving.

Other Girl Scout Favorites

There are plenty of other tasty Girl Scout cookies, although they don’t get nearly as much attention as the top three varieties. No matter what your favorite, there’s a healthy version out there to help you resist temptation.

Savannah Smiles

Image: Sugar-Free Mom

Miss the old lemony sweetness of the Savannah Smiles? Try these Sugar-Free Lemony Butter Cookies.


Image: Sift, Stir And Savour

A grain-free vegan version of Do-Si-Dos? Truly a mark of genius!


Image: The Low Carb Diet

The unassuming Trefoil gets a healthy makeover with these low-carb Shortbread Cookies.

Image: All Day I Dream About Food

Leave a Comment

Comments are closed.