Like two unstoppable forces on a collision course, you thought you would inevitably have to try Peeps milk.
You heard its siren call through the refrigerator doors at your supermarket, and even though you didn’t really want to, you knew that soon enough you would be pouring yourself a tall, cold glass of this spring’s hottest marshmallow-infused beverage.
Luckily, despite your intrigue, you don’t have to taste the stuff after all. The good folks over at Jimmy Kimmel Live!, including trusty sidekick Guillermo and American Idol judges Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban and Harry Connick, Jr., took the bullet for you and tasted Peeps milk on the show last night.
“It tastes like the circus. It tastes like what I imagine it would be like to be breastfed by a mother clown,” according to Jimmy. Yum?
You can see how the American Idol judges reacted below, then decide once and for all whether you really want to try Peeps milk for yourself.