After months of torturous waiting to find out who the body under the sheet was, HTGAWM fans were delivered a major shocker in the midseason finale: It was Wes! Yes, Wes. How can this be? Who killed him? Can someone please collect my jaw off the floor and return it to its rightful place?
Naturally, theories have been flying left and right since this jarring revelation. Here are the ones that’ll really make your head spin.