Double Take: Bradley Cooper, is that you?

May 19, 2011 at 8:01 p.m. ET

Is it just us? Or does American Idol season 10 castoff Paul McDonald look exactly like Bradley Cooper?

Paul McDonald may not be the next American Idol -- but he definitely reminds us of a certain other idol... Hangover 2 star Bradley Cooper.

Bradley Cooper and American Idol's Paul McDonald

The look-alike hunks certainly have a lot in common: Blue eyes. Perfect smiles.

Impeccable talent. Celebrity girfriends...

McDonald, who was booted off of American Idol after only the fifth week,  is reportedly dating Twilight hottie Nikki Reed.

The two "just moved in" together, according to an Us Weekly source. Oh la-la, Paul. Looks like things are getting serious pretty quickly.

Bradley Cooper is also quite the ladies man.

Though rumored to be single at the moment, Cooper has been linked to stars like Jennifer Aniston and Renee Zellwegger.

What do you think? Do Paul McDonald and Bradley Cooper look alike?

Tune in to Man Candy Mondays for more of our favorite hot dudes >>