“No Norm is the New Norm,” Vogue‘s Modern American Woman cover proclaims. But there’s a big problem: Their cover absolutely doesn’t represent true modern American women.
Sure, they’ve got some diversity in skin color and ethnicity — “some” being the key word — but that’s where the differences pretty much stop. Even the darker skin tones of the models aren’t all that dark.
Still, Vogue missed the whole point: Diversity isn’t just limited to skin color.
All of the women in the picture are small, like, itty-bitty, except for Graham, who is a plus-size model, but let’s be real; Graham fits in just fine among the other ladies. No one could ever call her “large,” though it is suspect that she is the only model in the photo with her hand on her leg.
The models are all also about the same height. Oh, and they have a lot of the same facial features, despite their diverse backgrounds.
I’m far from the only one who noticed these discrepancies.
Do you think Vogue know that having one 'plus size' model on their books, when the rest are 6ft + and size 4, doesn't make them diverse?
— Bethan 👑 (@bethanamyc) February 8, 2017
While they may be different ethnicities, they all have the same facial features & structure so is that even real diversity?
— Carolyn 'people pon scenes today' Hinds.😒 (@CarrieCnh12) February 8, 2017
The public to vogue: we need diversity!!
Vogue: *gets kendall and gigi again* pic.twitter.com/sGQdpWwqz8
— playboy bb (@angelmuxoz) February 8, 2017
If this is Vogue‘s most diverse cover yet, they really, really need to try again.
While Vogue has yet to comment on the controversy, Yahoo! reports Graham took to Instagram saying that she chose her pose for the cover. She added, “No one told me to do anything.”
But Graham’s pose is the least of Vogue‘s cover problems.
Before you go, check out our slideshow below.