What Sylvia Browne got right, and what she got so, so wrong

Nov 21, 2013 at 10:59 a.m. ET

Many of us only had a nodding acquaintance with Sylvia Browne, the high-profile psychic who passed away on Wednesday. So how will her body of work be remembered? For the things she got right, or for the things she got terribly wrong?

Sylvia Browne

What she got "right"

It's difficult to find much proof of what Sylvia Browne got right in her psychic predictions, leading one to wonder how she became so popular on shows like The Montel Williams Show and Larry King Live. She did predict that Arnold Schwarzenegger would run for political office before his campaign for governor of California. She also predicted that two people would be arrested for the Oklahoma City bombings. She prophesied that the Jon Benet Ramsey case would never be solved and that Madonna would have another kid by a different man. It's probably fair to say anyone could have made those last two "predictions."

Stallone & Schwarzenegger: Major rivals in the '80s >>

Image credit WENN.com

Not so right

We would never want to speak ill of the dead, but Browne's legacy is filled with predictions that she not only got wrong, but that caused family members undue stress and grief as a result of her false claims.

Two predictions that Browne has been criticized harshly for are related to the Amanda Berry and Shawn Hornbeck cases. She said Berry was dead, which as we all learned recently, the woman who was held hostage by Ariel Castro in Ohio is very much alive. When Browne was called out on her erroneous declaration, she said in a statement, "Only God is right all the time."

True life, I survived: Real stories from well-known women >>

In the case of 11-year-old Shawn Hornbeck, Browne told his parents he was dead and had been kidnapped by a dark-skinned man with dreadlocks. Five years later, Hornbeck was found alive and had been abducted by a Caucasian man with short hair.

Sylvia Browne

The Committee for Skeptical Inquiry published an article in March 2010 that studied 115 of Browne's predictions related to criminal cases. They found 25 to be completely wrong, and the remaining cases had no available details or remained unsolved, so there is no way to prove Browne's accuracy or lack thereof.

The study goes on to criticize details Browne provided to parents in criminal cases that increased their suffering. Browne told a grieving grandmother of a 6-year-old girl who was abducted from her yard in Texas that she had been sold into slavery and taken to Japan. Four years later authorities found the girls' remains in Texas.

Not all of Browne's false claims had to do with heinous crimes. A few of the lighter predictions she made, but also got wrong were:

"Volcanic eruption in Japan causes poisonous cloud mass in April (1998)." (What did Browne have against Japan?)

"David Letterman decides to call it quits from his nightly late show after this year (2000)."

David Letterman to stay on CBS through 2015 >>

"American troops will be pulled out of Iraq by June or July (2004)."

"Julia Roberts' marriage will end (2004)."

Browne also famously claimed she would die at the age of 88, but she was 77 when she passed away on Wednesday.

Image via Sylvia Browne Facebook