A mother was asked by a deputy to leave a courtroom to breastfeed her baby, and is now suing her county. Should they be made an example of for not following state law, or is this a frivolous lawsuit?

Nursing in public under fire, again

Natalie Petrovic, waiting in a courtroom to apply for food stamp benefits, was nursing her 7-week-old baby daughter in April when a female deputy insisted that she either stop breastfeeding her baby or feed her in the restroom. Worried about losing her benefits, she complied, but has now filed a lawsuit against Cook County in Illinois. Who was in the right here?

The letter of the law

The Right to Breastfeed Act, which passed in 2004, reads:

“A mother may breastfeed her baby in any location, public or private, where the mother is otherwise authorized to be, irrespective of whether the nipple of the mother's breast is uncovered during or incidental to the breastfeeding.”

Natalie, who was attempting to breastfeed in public for the first time, was nursing her little one under a cover when the deputy asked her to cease feeding her child or move to the bathroom. She knew that the deputy was likely in the wrong but she didn’t want to create a problem so she stopped nursing.

Illinois, like many other states in the U.S., has laws protecting a mother’s right to breastfeed her child at any location, public or private, that she is legally entitled to be. You don’t even need to have a cover — breastfeeding is your right and you cannot be asked to move, cover up, or stop nursing your child.

The lawsuit hopes to bring about an injunction to enforce this right in the courtroom as well as attorney’s fees and the cost of the lawsuit.

Attention-seeking lawsuit

"If ya can't feed your kid, don't have one!"

Some felt that this lawsuit was unnecessary and that women breastfeed in public for attention. “These women that do this are doing it for publicity on this issue,” stated a commenter on Huffington Post. “They can pump their breast milk into a bottle. If that's just to [sic] hard, breast feed in your car! Oh and for this woman, if ya can't feed your kid, don't have one!”     

Feed that baby, fight the good fight

Others feel that this mother was totally in the right for feeding her baby in public as well as filing a lawsuit. “You might realize that babies need to be fed or they die,” shared another commenter. “Perhaps women are nursing because their babies are hungry and need to be fed and breast milk is healthy food.”

Rachelle from Ohio agreed. “It is good grounds for a fight!” she told us.

Only time will tell what will happen with the lawsuit, but clearly the deputy was not in the right so it’s likely Natalie will win. And as more and more moms use their right to breastfeed in public, it’s hoped that the sight of nursing a baby won’t seem any stranger than seeing a little one drinking from a bottle.

Tell us

What do you think? Is this lawsuit frivolous or valid?

More on breastfeeding

Is breastfeeding in a military uniform taboo?
30 Famous breastfeeding moms
Breastfeeding a toddler and conquering challenges


Recommended for you


Comments on "Breastfeeding mom sues for courtroom discrimination"

Anouk June 05, 2012 | 1:07 AM

Amazing how some people are still so ignorant...! Breastfeeding is the most natural way to feed a child, we were given breast for that very purpose. I support this mother 110% and hope she wins big. We absolutly have to put an end to this non-sense in America.

Leigh June 04, 2012 | 7:18 PM

She was actually applying for WIC not food stamps! How the media skews the facts. Go Natalie for having the guts to stand up for your civil liberties and stand up for women nationally! It's good and healthy to breastfeed. You can't determine when your child will become hungry and need to eat. More power to you and women everywhere who decide to do provide the best in breastfeeding to their kids.

Julie June 04, 2012 | 10:17 AM

Not only should this mother win her lawsuit, it should sound a loud warning for people who have such a backward attitude about the most natural and child-healthy behavior a mom can choose. As for the Huffington Post commenter - he should have his keyboard revoked! What an idiot!

Miss Beazy June 04, 2012 | 7:36 AM

It is the most natural thing to breastfeed. If people have a problem with these women doing the right thing and breastfeeding their children...do not look at them! Why should a woman be forced to pump her milk and feed her child that way? Mind your own business and shut up!

+ Add Comment

(required - not published)