Judgment Vs. Personal Choice

Would you breastfeed another woman’s baby? Would you allow another woman to breastfeed your baby? While these questions may be hypothetical for you, they weren't for two women who met one day, formed a bond and shared something very personal.

mom breastfeeding baby boy

It was a year and a half ago that Catherine Connors of Her Bad Mother breastfed another woman's baby. The two women met at a conference. Connors was there without her baby and had forgotten her breast pump. She was in pain. Laura, another woman at the conference, was a breastfeeding mom whose baby was with her. Laura and Connors spent the morning together, talking and getting to know one another. And because Connors was in pain from being unable to nurse or pump, Laura suggested Connors breastfeed Laura's baby. The issue was recently revisited by Connors and a few other panelists for a Momversation video.

A simple solution?

In her blog post titled They Shoot Wet Nurses, Don't They?, Connors wrote the following: "I was grateful -- so, so grateful -- for Laura and her child; their generosity and open-mindedness and open-heartedness saved me a great deal of pain. At the end of the day, a mother was released from some considerable discomfort, and a child was nourished. Wonderful, no?"

Apparently not.

What Laura and Connors saw as a solution to an uncomfortable problem, another woman saw as unacceptable. The unidentified woman returned home and wrote a blog post about it -- one that drew agreement from many people and that, according to Connors, included attacks, particularly in the comments left by other readers. As a result, Connors wrote They Shoot Wet Nurses, Don't They?, where she explained what happened - - why she breastfed another woman's baby, the relationship she and the other woman, Laura, had developed and why she didn't think it was worthy of the criticism received. (The original blog post criticizing Connors was removed after Connors responded on her own blog.)

Is breastfeeding another woman's baby unheard of in "modern times?"

Not long before Connors breastfed Laura's baby, Salma Hayek was in Sierra Leone, where she breastfed a local baby on camera. While the reactions were mixed, she received a lot of praise.

Obviously the situations were different – in Hayek's case, she was breastfeeding a baby that was in need of nutrition and in Connors', she was breastfeeding another baby to relieve discomfort. But why the outrage over Connors' actions?

I don't have an answer. It seems that many women who commented put themselves in the situation when deciding whether what Connors did is "okay" with them. So, would you breastfeed another woman's baby? Moreover, would you allow another woman to breastfeed your baby?

It's an interesting question and one that many of the commenters provided an answer to on Connors' post. Perhaps most compelling was the fact that while many women said they would breastfeed another woman's baby, they probably wouldn't allow another woman to breastfeed their baby.

Health risks

Some people were concerned about the health risks of breastfeeding another woman's baby -- whether any diseases could be passed from a woman to a child. The Centers for Disease Control notes that a woman should not breastfeed under the following circumstances:

  • She has HIV
  • She is taking antiretroviral medications
  • She has untreated and active Tuberculosis
  • She uses illicit drugs
  • She is taking particular chemotherapy drugs
  • She is undergoing radiation therapies

The CDC further notes that it is unnecessary to use special precautions when handling breast milk: "The Universal Precautions to prevent transmission of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), Hepatitis B virus, and other bloodborne pathogens do not apply to human milk." Note that taking Universal Precautions and ingesting breast milk are not the same. However, the CDC discusses diseases that are transmittable through breast milk and the list doesn't appear to be long.

Connors noted that she and Laura had a conversation about health -- "Laura trusted me when I said that I was healthy and not taking anything that might compromise my milk. Perhaps this had everything to do with my appearance, or with the fact that I was obviously a nursing mother, or perhaps just with the fact that she had decided that I was simply worth trusting." Whether you would take another woman's word for it, Connors and Laura felt comfortable with each other, and that was enough for them.

Harsh judgment vs. personal opinions

Connors herself best summed it all up when she said, "You're welcome to say that you couldn't see yourself doing this; you are welcome, even, to cringe and shudder a bit in distaste. Whatever. We all have our issues. Just don't flaunt your disgust. And certainly don't use it to publicly shame mothers who make choices that you might not make." She encouraged women with differing opinions to share them, but asked that they remain respectful.

Most of us probably have an opinion on this issue. We moms have opinions on many parenting topics, from co-sleeping to breastfeeding in general to vaccinating. However, we should be able to have our opinions and express them in a way that isn't ugly. Simply because I don't believe I would have breastfed another woman's baby or allowed another woman to breastfeed my baby if I was in the situation does not mean I would think to -- or want to -- attack Connors or Laura.

>>So, what do you think about this? Watch Connors' brief video on Momversation. What would you do? Would you breastfeed another woman's baby? Would you allow another woman to breastfeed your baby? Vote in the poll and share your opinion in the comments section below.

Read more about breastfeeding


Recommended for you


Comments on "Would you breastfeed another woman’s baby?"

Sarah July 02, 2013 | 2:46 PM

I personally do not see any problem with it. I would be fine with nursing another woman's baby and vice verse. A baby is a baby.

Truthful Mommy January 20, 2011 | 12:13 PM

Well, I say I wouldn't on either case but that may be because I had such a difficult time breastfeeding myself. I NEVER produced enough milk and I had to use an SNS the entire time.I really think it would be dependent on the case because if it were one of my sisters or a good friend, I would absolutely do it but I don't think if it were anyone else I could do it. Maybe a starving, dying child, I could try to feed but honestly, it would just be a tease to the poor baby since I NEVER produced enough milk:( BUt I would never judge another mom who did it. It's not my business. Unlike the article I saw where the woman was breastfeeding a dog.

Naomi de la Torre January 18, 2011 | 2:13 AM

LOVED this article and yes, I would totally nurse a friend's baby. Also, after Diego had has tongue tie operation and my nipples were still healing from the trauma of trying to nurse him, a good friend of mine offered to nurse him while I was healing. It was the NICEST thing a friend could ever do, I thought. We didn't end up doing it, but I was so honored that she offered to help me in that way. But I'm glad she didn't after all. Because he was actually not able to nurse until he was 6 months old. Which is a whole other amazing story I can tell you sometime!

Klz January 17, 2011 | 7:13 PM

i would absolutely nurse another baby. What's he harm to me? That I nourished another life? He mother would have to be totally on with it but if someone asked me, I see no harm But I don't think I'd be able to get over my worry about someone else nursing my child. It's a control thing. I won't say never but I'd think about it much more

Rebecca January 17, 2011 | 10:36 AM

I am *almost* certain I would never nurse another baby or have someone else nurse my baby. I say almost because I can imagine situations where I might give the option some thought rather than my initial knee-jerk reaction of "Absolutely not!" That being said, this is another one of those things that in no way affects me. This was a choice made by two adults and they chose what they felt was best for them and their babies. And just because it isn't the choice I would make, doesn't mean it's not the right choice for someone else.

Lori January 17, 2011 | 10:20 AM

I find it interesting that those who advocate for prolonged breastfeeding - pointing often at cultures where it is considered typical and more "natural" - often overlook the fact that in those cultures, it is also typical for women to share breastfeeding responsibilities. Why is it okay to have breast-milk banks but not ok to get it from the source? It seems like perhaps the some of the same women who are trying to de-ualize breastfeeding so that it becomes more acceptable for breastfeeding moms to nurse in public are having a ualized reaction to the idea of a shared breast. (ie, not for "public" consumption)

katie. January 17, 2011 | 10:19 AM

An interesting debate -- I'm curious to see what people have to say. Honestly, I don't know how I feel on either side -- me breastfeeding another baby or having my baby breastfed by another woman. You certainly have me thinking! I do know someone who does this quite regularly and is very open minded about breastfeeding other people's children, if necessary or others breastfeeding her children -- I think I recall her being sick and having a diminished supply as a result, so a friend nursed her baby. The one thing I do know -- I certainly don't judge anyone who chooses this for themselves or their baby.

+ Add Comment

(required - not published)