Discipline Isn't

There are as many parenting techniques in the world as there are children. However, there are a few simple ideas parents can use to guide their choices in their task of raising mentally healthy children. "In some families, spanking is considered to be an effective form of discipline for children who misbehave," says Jeanne M Rohner, President of the Mental Health Association of Colorado. "However many parenting professionals agree that there are other more effective ways of disciplining children that do not cause the negative mental -- and sometimes physical -- impact on children."

Discipline vs punishment: Not just semantics

While punishment is a "penalty" for misbehavior, discipline is a method of teaching a child right from wrong. Punishment can be physical, as in spanking; or it can be psychological, as in expressing verbal disapproval, isolating a child in his or her room, or taking away a privilege. Discipline, on the other hand, is a tool that can help children learn self-control and take responsibility for their own behavior. Children who are raised with discipline techniques rather than punishment are more likely to understand their own behavior better, show independence, and respect themselves and others more.

Alternatives to physical discipline

While occasional, gentle spankings are not likely to cause children lasting damage, intense, repetitive spankings can lead to mental anguish in children, damage their self-esteem, increase their risk for depression, and leave them feeling bitter, resentful or angry. Intense spanking teaches children that violence is a way to solve problems and can lead to aggressive behavior in the future. Here are some positive and preventative alternatives to spanking:

  • Be a positive role model.Most children learn behaviors by observing their parents' actions. So parents must model the ways in which they want their children to behave.

  • Set rules and consequences.Make rules that are reasonable, fair, realistic and appropriate to a child's level of development. Explain the rules to children along with the consequences of not following them.

  • Encourage and reward good behavior.When children are behaving appropriately, tell them so. In addition to giving verbal praise, occasionally reward children with tangible objects, privileges or increased responsibility.

    For especially stressful times

    Even the best preventative disciplinary measures aren't foolproof! Children can reach the "melting point" and discipline becomes a reactive thing. Parents should keep in mind these positive reactive alternatives:

  • Give time outs. "Time outs" involve removing children from a situation following a negative behavior. This can help children calm down, establish control, end the inappropriate behavior and reenter the situation in a positive way. Make sure to explain what the inappropriate behavior is and why the time out is needed. Tell children when the time out will begin and how long it will last, and have them sit facing a wall away from distractions. Set an appropriate length for the time out based on age and level of development, usually just for a few minutes.

  • Constructive criticism.Once the child's temper and emotions are under control, sit with them and talk together about ways that their feelings might be handled differently in future situations. Offer positive suggestions and alternatives to their choice of actions.

  • Redirect. Redirecting the attention, particularly of a small child, is a good way to enforce positive behavior without resorting to spanking. This method is a disciplinary action to distract their unfavorable behavior away from someone or something, toward a healthier release.

    Every family, and every child, is different, but establishing a basic discipline plan early on helps when the rough spots occur. Consistent, clear messages about boundaries and behavior expectations will go a long way toward raising children into adults with good self-esteem and coping skills.

Recommended for you


Comments on "Alternatives to spanking: Positive parenting"

PDeverit May 19, 2009 | 11:49 PM

Child buttock-beating for the purpose of gaining compliance is nothing more than an inherited bad habit. Its a good idea for people to take a look at what they are doing, and learn how to DISCIPLINE instead of hit. I think the reason why television shows like Supernanny and Dr. Phil are so popular is because that is precisely what many (not all) people are trying to do . There are several reasons why hitting kids isn't a good idea. Here are a few good reads: Plain Talk About Spanking by Jordan Riak The ual Dangers of Spanking Children by Tom Johnson NO VITAL ORGANS THERE, So They Say by Lesli Taylor, M. D. and Adah Maurer, Ph. D.

nmay August 25, 2008 | 1:26 PM

We use many of the techniques listed above and find that positive reinforcement, timeouts, redirection, etc. seem to work much better than spanking. Spanking tends to make our kids more aggressive in general. The key to any discipline plan, I think, is remaining calm and consistent (although this can obviously be difficult at times when you have a child who is pushing you to your limits :)). There is a great debate about the use of spanking at www.opposingviews/questions/is-spanking-an-acceptable-form-of-discipline. Experts from both sides debate the issue and make some good points, especially about why spanking may not be as effective. Definitely worth a look!

+ Add Comment

(required - not published)