Share this Story

Battle of the flicks: Oblivion vs. To The Wonder

Shanee Edwards is a screenwriter who earned her master's degree at UCLA Film School. She recently won the Next MacGyver television writing competition to create a TV show about a female engineer. Her TV pilot, Ada and the Machine, is cur...

Which one should
you see this weekend?

Just as To The Wonder opens wide this weekend, sci-fi flick Oblivion has the potential to be a blockbuster hit. So, should you feed your inner romantic or channel your inner sci-fi nerd at the movie theater? Tough call!

Which one should  you see this weekend?


Tom Cruise stars in this sci-fi dystopian story about a futuristic Earth that's been ravaged by an alien invasion.

Scavengers called "Scavs" now roam the planet, but are they as dangerous as everyone thinks?

Cruise, Olga Kuryenko and Andrea Riseborough give stunning performances in this film that's full of amazing IMAX visuals. The story however, starts out strong but gets a bit confusing about half way through. This certainly shouldn't deter any die-hard sci-fi fans from seeing it.

Here's what some other gals thought:

Catherine Bray of said, "Oblivion's leading man is as dependable as ever, and can sell an action set piece like few of his contemporaries. A shame that the film, while pretty, is somewhat ponderous, and ultimately fails to cohere into a narratively satisfying whole."

Ali Gray of said, "Convincing as a crowd-pleasing action blockbuster while containing all the necessary requirements for solid science-fiction, Oblivion casts its net wide but only falls short of greatness when it comes to its drab script, lacking the necessary wit or eloquence to elevate the exposition."

Louise Keller of Urban Cinefile said, "Elements from Total Recall, Solaris and Moon orbit the narrative of this heralded, overlong Tom Cruise sci-fi action thriller that does its best to dazzle by its myriad of special effects, videogame-esque sequences and a plot that pretty well succeeds at confusing itself."

You can read my full review here:

Oblivion movie review: Tom Cruise punches Tom Cruise? >>

Which one should  you see this weekend?

To The Wonder

Ben Affleck plays a man torn between two women, unable to commit to either.

This movie is about as "art-house" of a film as you can get. Director Terrance Malick (Tree of Life) uses visual landscapes to stand in for emotional states and mental fragility.

Basically, the film is lovely to look at, but has very little dialogue and will probably leave most audience members disappointed.

Check out these reviews from other women:

Betsy Sharkey of The Los Angeles Times said, "Between the style and the substance, it is likely to leave some loving the film, others loathing it, probably for many of the same reasons."

Nell Minnow of said, "If you thought Tree of Life was too linear and accessible try this pointillist tribute to sun flares, often lovely, sometimes provocative, always obscure."

Lisa Kennedy of The Denver Post said, "'To the Wonder' sketches Neil, Marina, Jane. It makes their yearning, hurts, melancholy atmospheric. Their love is attractive and vague. Too often, the movie has the feel of a Calvin Klein "Eternity" ad.

But you can always read my full review:

To the Wonder movie review: Beautiful torture >>

Which one should  you see this weekend?


The SheKnows movie winner of the week is Oblivion for its futuristic, sci-fi world that excites visually.

Photo credit: Oblivion courtesy of Universal and To The Wonder courtesy of Magnolia Pictures.

Follow Us

SheKnows Media ‐ Entertainment

New in Entertainment

And you'll see personalized content just for you whenever you click the My Feed .

SheKnows is making some changes!

b h e a r d !

Welcome to the new SheKnows Community,

where you can share your stories, ideas

and CONNECT with millions of women.

Get Started