Books To Film: Which Is Better?

Some of the best movies and television series were born from the pages of a book. Here are five books that made it to the screen: Read them, and then see them and decide which version you like better.

One for the Money

One for the Moneyby Janet Evanovich

Unemployed and desperate, Stephanie Plum is forced to con her cousin, a New Jersey bail bondsman, into giving her a job. Stephanie thinks she's sitting pretty until she's given her first assignment: Bring in Joe Morelli, who's not only a cop but a childhood friend. Okay, so Morelli was a bit more than just a friend, and Stephanie is having one heck of a time capturing him. Funny and smart with some great plot twists and two hot guys, One for the Money is a top notch start to an entertaining series. The movie, starring Katherine Heigl and Jason O'Mara, opens in theaters on Jan. 27. Bonus: If you like sassy, humorous cozy mysteries, try the Bubbles Yablonsky series by Sarah Strohmeyer, which starts with Bubbles Unbound.

The Descendants

The Descendantby Kaui Hart Hemmings

Matthew King, a descendant of Hawaiian royalty, is at a crisis point. His fast-living wife is in a coma after suffering an accident, his daughters are totally out of control and his cousins are hounding him about the family trust. When he learns of his wife's secret life, Matt is forced to take stock of himself, his life and his responsibilities. The Descendants is a heart-warming story of forgiveness and healing. The movie, starring George Clooney, Shailene Woodley and Amara Miller, is in theaters now. Bonus: If you like books about marriages, secrets and parent–child bonds, try Caroline Leavitt's Pictures of You.

The Help

The Helpby Kathryn Stockett

When Skeeter Phelan moves back home after graduating college in the 1960s, she's no longer comfortable with the social and racial divides her Mississippi parents take for granted. After seeing her town with fresh eyes, she decides to give a voice to some of the thousands of black women who have devoted their lives to serving white families. Risking everything, Skeeter and two black housekeepers collect stories from the town's "help," setting off an avalanche of reactions and change. The Help inspires us to follow our hearts and stand up for what we know is right; it's also a story of friendship, heartache and hope. The movie, starring Emma Stone, Viola Davis and Octavia Spencer, is out on DVD and BluRay. Bonus: If you like to read about women's relationships in the South in the 1960s, try Sue Monk Kidd's The Secret Life of Bees.

Snow Flower and the Secret Fan

Snow Flower and the Secret Fanby Lisa See

Women led sheltered lives in 19th-century China, constrained by duty to their families and husbands. Lily and Snow Flower were lucky to have each other, bonded at age seven to be lifelong friends. Against a backdrop of marriages, wars and cultural limitations, the two women struggle to hold on to their true selves and their relationship. See's attention to historical detail and skill at creating sympathetic characters will make Snow Flower and the Secret Fan one your favorite books. The movie, starring Li Bingbing and Gianna Jun, is out on DVD and BluRay. Bonus: For another book about women's friendships, try The Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood by Rebecca Wells.

The Vampire Diaries

The Vampire Diariesby L. J. Smith

One of the earliest and most enduring vampire series starts with The Awakening, which introduces us to vampire brothers Stefan and Damon Salvatore, who have been competing for women since they were first turned into the undead more than 150 years ago. In modern times, the Salvatores return to their Virginia hometown, where they focus their attention on Elena Gilbert. The human teenager is caught in the middle, forced to chose sides. The television series The Vampire Diaries, starring Paul Wesley, Ian Somerhalder and Nina Dobrev, airs on the CW and is in its third season; check your local listings for the day and time. Bonus: If you're fan of vampires and the paranormal, try Richelle Mead's Vampire Academy series, starting with Vampire Academy.

More book ideas

SheKnows Book Club: Join us!
Q&A with bestselling author Kristin Hannah
What's on Kristin Hannah's nightstand?


Recommended for you


Comments on "Read it first: January's books to read then see the movie"

Robert Bordelon January 13, 2012 | 1:32 PM

Well I think One for the Money is the best hands down and has a longer lasting series than the others. Go Stephanie Plum!!!!!

Chrissy January 13, 2012 | 1:32 PM

I am so excited for One for the Money!!! I have read through book 17 (working on 18 now) and each time I can't wait for the next installment. After reading so far into the story, it will be interesting to go back to book 1 with the movie. Janet Evanovich is a fantastic author and I'm hoping there is much more yet to come with this series!

Lenore Appelhans January 11, 2012 | 1:44 PM

Very entertaining column, Candace! I used to always try to read the book before seeing the movie, but it seems there are so many adaptions lately, I feel like I can't possibly get to them all.

Caroline Leavitt January 11, 2012 | 1:39 PM

Candace is fantastic! What a great column and thank you, Candace, for mentioning my book.

Ellen Brown January 11, 2012 | 10:19 AM

I just read Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, enjoyed it, and then immediately dived into the movie. What a disappointment. I spent most of the move explaining to my husband, who had not read the book, what was going on. If you didn't already know the story, the random series of scenes on film would make no sense. The acting was good and the visuals great, but for me the magic of the story was lost in the movie. In this case, the book wins by a landslide.

Sarah McCoy January 11, 2012 | 9:55 AM

Candace is the absolute best! I am so thrilled to see her new column and have bookmarked it for future reading. Great addition She Knows team, and great post, Candace!

+ Add Comment

(required - not published)