What would you like to know?
Share this Story

Supergirl's Winn episode met with some major backlash from fans

Sarah grew up in Monterey, CA and now lives in Los Angeles. When she's not writing, you can find her enjoying a good book, fine wine, sunflowers and long walks on the beach.

Winn finally steals the spotlight on Supergirl, but the story line wasn't what fans were hoping for

In tonight's episode of Supergirl, titled "Childish Things," the Winn character finally stepped out of the shadows and into a more developed plotline of his own. A solid Winn story line is something many of us have been hoping for a while, but — despite a solid performance by Jeremy Jordan — the writers' treatment of Winn's episode pissed off viewers and let down fans.

Everything started off on the right foot, with Winn battling his own inner demons as his father, the villainous Toyman, escapes from prison and starts threatening public safety. Caught up in the overwhelming emotions he's dealing with, Winn kisses Kara, which, of course, she brutally rebuffs.

Winn finally steals the spotlight on Supergirl, but the story line wasn't what fans were hoping for
Image: Monty Brinton/CBS

Later in the episode, Winn professes his love to Kara and tells her he's been in love with her since before she was Supergirl, which was super overdue. The confession was courageous, heartfelt and instantly won a ton of viewers over — because who hasn't dealt with the sting of unrequited love?

More: Supergirl's new villain may become the best character on the show

Kara politely rebuffs him again, using the age-old "I don't want to ruin our friendship" excuse, and this is where things quickly go downhill for Winn and his story line. Winn doesn't handle the rejection well and paves the way for turning into a villain himself.

Here's what had fans up in arms.

Winn's reaction to Kara turning him down is dangerous

Some fans felt what Winn had to say after Kara turned him down was a completely inappropriate response to the situation. The "I can't keep bottling things up" speech seemed vaguely threatening and many have theorized that Winn will use the rejection as an excuse to turn evil. Can you image what kind of world we would live in if everyone used getting shot down as an excuse to get violent?

It was a male-oriented episode

Supergirl's whole deal is that the show is supposed to be a girl power extravaganza, and this episode most definitely was not.

The writing reinforces guilty feelings women deal with every day

Again, coming from a feminist-themed show, the idea that Kara should even entertain the thought that Winn's feelings and behavior are her fault is not cool. The writers didn't even have Alex tell Kara it wasn't her fault when she ran to her sister about the situation.

Love triangles are tired

Supergirl fans have made it loud and clear: They are into the show for action sequences and female empowerment, not soapy hook-up subplots.

General discontent

Quite a few Supergirl viewers are just over Winn, plain and simple.

While I do agree Winn's reaction to Kara turning him down was completely unfair, I also personally believe making the character a villain is the only way to preserve his story line on the show. Otherwise, he's just stale.

What do you think? Are you Team Winn or Team Winn GTFO?

New in Entertainment

And you'll see personalized content just for you whenever you click the My Feed .

SheKnows is making some changes!