SECTIONS
What would you like to know?
Share this Story
/

Doctor Strange fans point out a 'problem' with new female cast member

Katie McKay-Phillips is a freelance writer and the creator of Ruffled Feathers, an online wedding and event style brand. She lives in Chicago with her husband, son and two English bulldogs. Katie is a Highland Games competitor and streng...

Tilda Swinton to join Doctor Strange cast as controversial 'new' character

It's no Black Widow movie, but the shift toward using women in more leading roles in comic book movies sure is encouraging.

Recently, it was just announced that Tilda Swinton is in talks with Marvel to join the cast of Doctor Strange to play the Ancient One, a Tibetan mystic who is a mentor to Dr. Strange, played by Benedict Cumberbatch.

More: Can you name the Benedict Cumberbatch movie from one still? (QUIZ)

The original character was written as a male role and, originally Marvel Studios was looking for a male actor. But after retooling it, they have now decided to make the Ancient One a woman.

Now, I love Tilda Swinton. She is an Oscar-winning actress, and I've never seen her in anything I didn't love. But it is hard to not ask the question: Why not an Asian woman? Is this another case of whitewashing movies?

More: How Stan Lee is bringing women and minorities to the comic world (INTERVIEW)

While seemingly eternally adaptable, Swinton is not nor can ever be of Asian descent.

And the internet jumped on that fact immediately.

Comments have been rolling in asking why they didn't look for or choose an Asian actress for the role.

On a Hollywood Reporter article, one (aptly named) commenter, cynic000, very eloquently pointed out, "This news is somewhat unsettling for me. On the one hand, casting a woman to play The Ancient One is a brilliant move and Swinton is a superb actress. On the other, why not cast an Asian woman in this pivotal, and originally Asian, role? Yeoh, Liu, Ling and any of a dozen Asian actresses would be excellent choices. Hollywood does a woeful job of employing Asians as a rule so race-swapping this role might be a rather bad idea."

Tilda Swinton to join Doctor Strange cast as controversial 'new' character

Then there are the more critical comments, like Solid Snake's, "whitewashing and gender swapping in one move that is a new record congrats marvel."

solid snake comment

One outraged commenter asked, "Will Swinton wear yellowface to look Asian?"

There are dozens of comments along these lines, several pointing out other times that Marvel movies swapped, like Batman running into Liam Neeson in the Himalayas.

So, while it is great to see women being moved into more roles, it looks like we still have a long way to go for equality in Hollywood.

More: 10 Things I learned about Doctor Strange today

Tilda Swinton to join Doctor Strange cast as controversial 'new' character

Comments
Hot
New in Entertainment
Close

And you'll see personalized content just for you whenever you click the My Feed .

SheKnows is making some changes!