SECTIONS
What would you like to know?
Share this Story
/

Girlfriends' Guide to Divorce: 5 Reasons I loved the premiere

Julie Robinson

by

Entertainment Writer

Julie Robinson, @juliecrob, has decided that the title of “Pop Culture Junkie” gives her permission to indulge in reality TV with nary a guilt twinge. She misses “Six Feet Under” and “Nip/Tuck”, has a few logistical questions for the fo...

Show of hands if you watched and loved Girlfriends' Guide to Divorce last night

I'm a network whore. With absolutely no loyalty, I partake of whatever tickles my fancy while watching TV in bed.

Girlfriends' Guide to Divorce creator on Tinder, sexual politics

I hop from ABC to PBS to E! to Showtime while between the sheets — the shows that prove to be the highest bidders are the ones that get my repeat business. I'm already a Bravo regular, so when the reality TV mecca announced its first scripted series, I was game. So what constitutes as a high bidder to this TV critic?

In the case of #GG2D, here's what'll keep me coming around

1. The dialogue

When a show opens with a husband (Jake) sneaking into his marital bed at the crack of dawn, you know something's up. But when his wife (Abby) whispers, "You smell like sex," and he comes back with, "Screw you," I'm hooked.

2. Charlie, the son

Still reveling in the above salty exchange, I was soon rewarded again by the character of Jake and Abby's grade-school son at the family breakfast table. At first glance the scenario appears to be a 2014 version of the Cleavers, but then Charlie muses, "Is it weird that I like the smell of my own farts?" Bam. This could simply be another example of dialogue that draws me in, but I predict it's the character himself. Whether he was egging his mother on by proclaiming, "Penis, penis, penis," or being a vulnerable kid who realizes that he's about to be from a broken family, Charlie has a fan in me.

3. Abby's career

She's a personal growth author who draws from her happy family for material. As a personal growth author who once lamented about making star-shaped croutons for the perfect Christmas, methinks I'm going to enjoy Abby's unraveling. (Shameless plug alert: Live in the Moment, Atria Books, makes an excellent holiday gift for women of all ages.)

4. The cameos

When was the last time you saw Carrie Fisher without honey-bun braids for ear covers? From the looks of next week's episode, Bernadette Peters will be swinging by crazy town.

5. I liked the dialogue so much I'm going to give it some more love

"Her dad trolls for dates at One Direction concerts."

"Are you in a Tab commercial?"

"At least I don't wake up smelling like Astroglide."

"My vagina is not dead; it was in a coma."

"Screw you and your past tense."

EXCLUSIVE: First look at Girlfriends' Guide to Divorce (VIDEO)


Here's what I'm iffy about

1. Phoebe

At first glance, Abby's friend comes off as vapid, cryptic and, dare I say, even a little creepy. Sure, she's gorgeous, and when she laid a big wet kiss on Abby because she "needed to be touched," it was a nice little surprise. This BFF relationship left me cold.

2. Abby's gay brother Max

Newly married and celebratory of his hard-fought right to do so, he's none too pleased with his sister's crumbling union with Jake. On paper this dynamic sounds like a meaty nuance, yes? Not so much on-screen.

3. Divorcée clichés

Fake boob pride, nightclub crawlers and walks of shame through an apartment full of 20-something video gamers — none of which leave me with high hopes about a new look at the female midlife crisis.

4. Vicious, bitter women

Lyla, Abby's other bestie, gives in to a "one for the road" romp with her ex-husband, swills wine from the bottle in lieu of pillow talk and when he hits the road, she calls the cops to report a drunk driver.

5. Pill popping

At the first sign of Abby's meltdown upon realizing that her marriage is indeed toast, her besties offer her a slew of pills, aka "Vicodoodles." (I'm conflicted on this point, however, because the dialogue that spews from Abby's mouth at her pill-fueled Barnes & Noble book signing is priceless. She admits to her audience that her newest book about domestic happiness is "a pile of horseshit.")

Whether GG2D lives up to the comparisons to Sex and the City as an iconic female rite of passage, fizzles out or charters a territory that's entirely its own, I'm in. You?

Want more TV news, reviews and interviews? Sign up for our newsletter


Let us know your thoughts on Girlfriends' Guide to Divorce in the comments below.

Tagged in
Comments
Hot
New in Entertainment
Close

And you'll see personalized content just for you whenever you click the My Feed .

SheKnows is making some changes!