Fact Meets Fiction
In Starz's New Series

I'm never quite sure if giving a series an early premiere online is a show of good faith or not, but Black Sails was given the special treatment. Did it need the help?

Black Sails Premiere Review

I'm just going to admit right here and now that I enjoy Michael Bay productions. Throw snowballs at me or whatever makes you feel better, but as cheesy as his shows can be, I find them entirely enjoyable. So when I learned Bay would be involved with the Starz series Black Sails — co-created by Robert Levine (Harper's Island) and Jonathan E. Steinberg (Jericho) — I was immediately interested. The other series the co-creators have been involved with were also fantastic. It seems like a situation where these men just can't lose with Black Sails.

Watch the Black Sails premiere online right now! >>

The most important aspect of any successful television series — in my not-so-humble opinion — is the ability to establish characters that resonate with the viewers. Doing that in a short period of time is also high on the list. Black Sails nailed it.

It's easy to see what Black Sails got from Bay. The opening and closing scenes of the premiere were typical Bay fare — lavishly produced action sequences. The opener was a pirate attack on a ship, and it included sailors falling from crumbling masts and cannonballs hitting their marks. The closer required a sword fight followed by pounding fists with the appropriate bloodletting. Good stuff.

Starz's Outlander trailer: Claire Randall falls through time >>

From Levine and Steinberg, I see richly written characters that within one hour are already imbued with personality. John Silver (Luke Arnold), who will one day be a villain in Robert Louis Stevenson's novel Treasure Island, is for now a confident young man. He's a bit on the cocky side, but he can win you over with a smile while stealing money from your pocket. Still, you'd want to have a drink with him.

Captain Flint (Toby Stephens) is a man who has played his cards too close to the vest for too long, and now he's close to losing the respect of his crew. By his own lights, he believes himself to be aloof, overeducated for his status and unlucky. It's only when Flint's third-in-command, Billy Bones (Tom Hopper), lets it slip that the men think he's weak that Flint springs into action.

Bones is the moral compass of the pirates, if such a person can be said to exist. At one point in the episode, he aims a rifle at Flint to keep him from harming someone, but during a later skirmish, Bones mistakenly shoots the man he saved. It's not a perfect world, by any means.

Flint has had his eye on the Urca de Lima, a Spanish galleon carrying millions in cargo, but he hasn't shared the information for fear of deception and backstabbing. A man on Flint's own ship ends up getting the information Flint needs most, but it would appear the series will be about Flint and Silver (who has the information) working together toward a common goal, even if not as partners. Perhaps they will be partners — it's information I'm not privy to!

Ahoy, matey! Get to know the characters of Black Sails >>

Working on the island is Eleanor Guthrie (Hannah New), who apparently once had a thing for Flint's rival — Captain Vane (Zach McGowan), one of the "real" pirates of the era. She also has a thing for girls. After Eleanor is in a fistfight with Vane, she is cared for by Max (one of the lovable whores), who's played by Jessica Parker Kennedy. Max cares for Eleanor with tender, loving care that errs a bit more toward the loving than the tender, if you catch my drift.

The unique combination of fictional characters from Stevenson's novel, real people who sailed the seas and new characters written to interact between fiction and history seems to work really well and makes the show a different kind of history lesson. It helps us imagine what Stevenson was thinking as he wrote his novel while giving us a look at what it was like for real pirates in their heyday, without the romanticized fluff we've come to expect.

Video: Michael Bay's meltdown at CES >>

The bottom line is this: I really liked the characters. Everyone who graced the screen was written in a gray area, and there are no good guys or bad guys. It's the perfect environment where a pirate world can flourish. This microcosm is about to be under attack from civilization, so at the top of the pirates' priority list is protecting their world. Flint wants the Urca de Lima bounty to fortify his little part of the earth against outsiders — not the pirates' personal enemies, but the creeping urban sprawl that we suffer every day. It's too bad we already know how the story will end. The pirates who sail the seas today are not the ones of Black Sails.

The premiere gets two thumbs up from me. I think that it was fun and that it created a world I would be interested in visiting, with people I'd want to know. What more could you possibly ask for from a series premiere?

Image courtesy of Starz


Recommended for you


Comments on "Black Sails review: The hunt for pirate treasure is on"

Jack January 27, 2014 | 9:35 AM

F-Bombs are unnecessary in storytelling, but pretty light considering the era. The "Blackbeard" scene was unnecessary, too, but this shock-value content is supposed to fade in future episodes. Nobody wants to see pretty girls with ugly teeth. It's not shooting for total accuracy. The same with the dollars bit. It's easy to explain in modern terms. Would you rather them go through the charade of explaining the monetary unit to each other when they should know already? (Besides "The real de a ocho, is also known as the Spanish dollar, the eight-real coin, or the piece of eight")

Denis January 27, 2014 | 4:36 AM

What looked promising turned dismal. First of all the F bombs were over the top< the pretty girls with perfect teeth , come on now, and using the term dollars when there wan no such thing as a dollar at the time. The ships and scenery were good and so is the story line but such things as the gratuitous scene take away form the movie.

+ Add Comment

(required - not published)